Install Sangha One for a better experience

Healing

Why Is This Happening to Me? Suffering, Karma and What the Traditions Actually Say

Please note. This is spiritual and educational content. It is not medical, psychological or financial advice, and it is not a substitute for your GP, a psychologist or a financial counsellor. Nothing here is a treatment or cure for any condition.
If you need support now. In Australia, call Lifeline on 13 11 14 (24 hours) or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636 (24 hours). In an emergency, or if you are thinking of harming yourself, call 000. Outside Australia, contact your local crisis line or doctor.

Would it help to talk with someone? See what a guidance session is like, or book a private conversation with Keshab when you are ready. It is spiritual conversation, not therapy or treatment.

In short. “Why is this happening to me?” is one of the oldest spiritual questions, and the traditions take it seriously. Two things are worth knowing straight away. First, the Buddha said plainly that not everything a person suffers is the result of past karma (Samyutta Nikaya 36.21), and the Gita calls the workings of karma hard to fathom (4.17). No one is entitled to tell you that you deserved this. Second, both traditions turn the question from “why?” towards “what now?”: how to bear what has come, and how to act well inside it (Gita 2.14; Majjhima Nikaya 63).

The question is honoured

The Bhagavad Gita begins with a man in collapse asking what he should do, and Krishna counts those who turn to God out of distress among the noble (7.16, 7.18). The Buddha’s first teaching opens with the plain statement that birth, ageing, death, sorrow, separation from what we love and not getting what we want are suffering (Samyutta Nikaya 56.11). Neither tradition treats pain as a sign that something is wrong with you. They treat it as part of being alive, and as the place where serious inquiry tends to start.

Is this my karma?

Karma means that actions have results. It is often flattened into “everything that happens to you is payback”, and both traditions reject that reading.

A wanderer named Sivaka asked the Buddha whether everything a person feels is caused by past action. The Buddha said no. Some of what we feel arises from the body’s own disorders, from the change of seasons, from careless behaviour, from injury, and some from the results of karma; to claim it is all past karma goes beyond what anyone knows (Samyutta Nikaya 36.21). Elsewhere he listed the precise working out of karma among the things that cannot be figured out by thinking, and said that trying brings only vexation (Anguttara Nikaya 4.77).

The Gita says the same in four words: the way of action is deep and hard to understand (4.17). So when someone tells a sick person, a grieving parent or a victim of wrongdoing that it must be their karma, they are claiming a knowledge the Buddha and Krishna both said people do not have. In these traditions karma is taught so that we take care with what we do next. It was never meant as a verdict on anyone’s past.

The question the Buddha set aside

A monk once told the Buddha he would leave unless certain ultimate questions were answered. The Buddha replied with a picture: a man is struck by a poisoned arrow, and refuses to have it removed until he knows who shot it, from what family, with what kind of bow. He would die first. The teaching, the Buddha said, is for removing the arrow (Majjhima Nikaya 63).

“Why me?” is sometimes a question that can be answered: a cause can be found and something can be learned. Often it cannot, and waiting for the answer keeps the arrow in. The traditions allow you to leave the “why” open and still be helped.

What can be known and done

The Gita’s first practical word on pain is that the contacts that bring pleasure and pain come and go and do not last; bear them (2.14). This is not a dismissal, since it is said to a man in tears by a friend who then stays for seventeen more chapters. It is a fact that can be leaned on: this, too, has a beginning and an end.

The Buddha distinguished the pain that life brings from the further suffering we add by blaming ourselves, resisting and dreading (Samyutta Nikaya 36.6). The first is often outside our control. The second can be eased. Patanjali states the aim briefly: the suffering that has not yet come can be avoided (Yoga Sutras 2.16).

And the Gita defines yoga itself as the unlinking from union with pain, to be practised with resolve and without a despairing mind (6.23). The tradition’s promise is modest and real. It does not say hard things will stop happening. It says a person can come to stand differently in relation to them.

Practices for a hard season

When to get more help

Sources

Summaries and paraphrases are our own; scripture references are given so you can read the texts in a translation you trust.

Common questions

Is my suffering caused by bad karma?
No one can tell you that. The Buddha said that not everything a person feels is the result of past karma, naming bodily, seasonal and accidental causes as well (Samyutta Nikaya 36.21), and the Gita calls the workings of karma hard to understand (4.17).
What does the Bhagavad Gita say about suffering?
That pleasure and pain come and go and are to be borne (2.14), that those who turn to God in distress are noble (7.16, 7.18), and that yoga is the unlinking from union with pain, practised with resolve (6.23).
Why do bad things happen to good people?
The traditions do not give a single tidy answer. The Buddha compared the demand for one to refusing treatment for an arrow wound until you know who shot it (Majjhima Nikaya 63). They offer instead ways to bear pain, ease the suffering we add to it, and act well.

If you are in the middle of something hard and asking why, you can speak privately with Keshab. It is a spiritual conversation, not therapy or medical advice, and it will not tell you that you deserved what happened. Talk with Keshab.

In the glossary: Karma · Dukkha · Equanimity · Samsara
Related: The three kinds of karma · Karma, dharma, samsara and moksha · The four noble truths · Doubt and loss of faith · Spiritual support in grief · Spiritual support in serious illness · Guilt and regret · Anxiety and worry · The four kinds of seekers in Gita 7.16
More in Healing: Spiritual Practices for Anxiety and Worry: What the Gita and the Buddha Offer · Stress and Burnout: A Spiritual Perspective from the Gita and the Buddha · Loneliness: Spiritual Practices for Feeling Alone · Heartbreak and the End of a Relationship: A Spiritual Perspective · Anger: Spiritual Practices for Working with Anger · Fear: Spiritual Practices for Courage and Steadiness · Overthinking: How to Quiet a Busy Mind, from the Gita and the Buddha · Sleeplessness: Gentle Spiritual Practices for Restless Nights · Money Worry and Debt Anxiety: A Spiritual Perspective · Losing a Job: A Spiritual Perspective on Redundancy and Starting Again · Career Confusion: Finding Your Svadharma · Business Setbacks and Failure: A Spiritual Perspective · Wealth and Dharma: The Right Relationship with Money in Hindu and Buddhist Teaching · The Path of Knowledge: Self-Inquiry and Vedanta for Advanced Seekers · Spiritual Healing vs Therapy: What Each Offers, and When You Need Which · Life Coach vs Spiritual Guide vs Psychologist: Which Do You Need? · What a Spiritual Healer Does, and What They Should Never Claim · Finding a Spiritual Healer or Guide, Near You or Online · Spiritual Guidance for Anxiety: What It Can Offer, and How It Fits with Therapy · Spiritual Counselling in Australia: Chaplains, Counsellors and Spiritual Guides · Finding a Meditation Teacher Online: What to Look For · Spiritual Support After a Death: Where to Find It and What Helps · Spiritual Support for Low Mood and Depression, Alongside Treatment · What Happens in a Spiritual Guidance Session, and How to Prepare · Spiritual Support for Carers: Looking After Someone Without Losing Yourself · Far From Home: Spiritual Support for Migrants and Families Abroad · Spiritual Support During Serious Illness, for You or Someone You Love · Spiritual Guidance on Life Purpose: What Am I Here For? · Spiritual Support After Miscarriage, Stillbirth or the Loss of a Baby · Spiritual Guidance for Marriage and Relationship Problems · Spiritual Support in Recovery from Alcohol, Drugs or Gambling · Spiritual Guidance for a Big Decision: Seeing Clearly When You Are Torn · Finding an Online Sangha: Spiritual Community When You Cannot Get to One · After Losing Money to a Scam or a Bad Investment: A Spiritual Perspective · Money Pressure in the Family: Supporting Parents, Sending Money Home and Saying No · A Difficult Workplace: Conflict, Unfair Treatment and Bullying, from a Spiritual Perspective · Guilt and Regret: A Spiritual Perspective on Forgiving Yourself · Fear of Death: A Spiritual Perspective and Gentle Practices · Exam Stress and Study Pressure: A Spiritual Perspective for Students · Doubt and Loss of Faith: A Spiritual Perspective · Divorce and Separation: A Spiritual Perspective · Worried About Your Child: A Spiritual Perspective for Parents · Ageing and Retirement: A Spiritual Perspective on Growing Older · When Spiritual Practice Feels Dry: Plateaus, Boredom and Keeping Going · Family Conflict and Estrangement: A Spiritual Perspective · Midlife Crisis: A Spiritual Perspective on “Is This All There Is?” · Family Pressure to Marry: A Spiritual Perspective · Do You Need a Guru or Spiritual Teacher? What the Gita, the Upanishads and the Buddha Say · Betrayal and Broken Trust: A Spiritual Perspective · Gambling: What the Vedas, the Mahabharata and the Buddha Say, and Where to Get Help · Ageing Parents Overseas: A Spiritual Perspective on Caring From Afar · Living With In-Laws: A Spiritual Perspective on Conflict in a Joint Family · Returning to Spiritual Practice After Years Away · all healing

Walk with us

One passage, one question, every Sunday. Nothing else, ever.