Install Sangha One for a better experience

Healing

Doubt and Loss of Faith: A Spiritual Perspective

Please note. This is spiritual and educational content. It is not medical, psychological or financial advice, and it is not a substitute for your GP, a psychologist or a financial counsellor. Nothing here is a treatment or cure for any condition.
If you need support now. In Australia, call Lifeline on 13 11 14 (24 hours) or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636 (24 hours). In an emergency, or if you are thinking of harming yourself, call 000. Outside Australia, contact your local crisis line or doctor.

Would it help to talk with someone? See what a guidance session is like, or book a private conversation with Keshab when you are ready. It is spiritual conversation, not therapy or treatment.

In short. Doubt is not the opposite of a spiritual life. The Buddha told the Kalama people that it was fitting for them to be uncertain, and asked them to test teachings against their own experience (Anguttara Nikaya 3.65). The Gita is a book of questions: Arjuna asks all the way through, and Krishna ends by saying, reflect on this fully, then do as you wish (18.63). The traditions warn only about the kind of doubt that never settles on anything (4.40). If losing your faith has come with low mood, isolation or conflict at home, you do not have to carry that alone.

Two kinds of doubt

There is the doubt of someone who wants to know, and so asks, reads, tests and listens. This is what the Gita calls the seeker of knowledge, one of the four kinds of people Krishna names as good (7.16).

And there is a wavering that distrusts everything, including its own conclusions, and so cannot act. Buddhist teaching lists this among the hindrances, and the Gita says of it that the one who doubts everything finds no happiness in this world or the next (4.40). The remedy it gives is understanding: cut this doubt, born of not knowing, with the sword of knowledge (4.42). Suppressing the doubt is not what is asked.

The traditions make room for questions

The Kalamas told the Buddha that every teacher who came through praised his own doctrine and ran down the others, and they did not know whom to believe. He answered that their uncertainty was reasonable, and that they should not go by report, tradition, scripture or the standing of a teacher alone, but by whether a teaching, taken up and practised, leads to harm or to wellbeing (Anguttara Nikaya 3.65).

The Rig Veda’s hymn of creation ends with a question: who really knows where this creation came from? Perhaps the one who looks down from the highest heaven knows, or perhaps even he does not (10.129). And at the end of the Gita, having taught for eighteen chapters, Krishna does not command. He says: reflect on it fully, then do as you wish (18.63).

When faith goes quiet

Faith often falters after a loss, an illness, a prayer that seemed to go unanswered, or a betrayal by a teacher or a community. Sometimes it simply fades as a person’s thinking changes. None of these makes you a bad person or a failed devotee.

It may help to know what the tradition means by faith. Shraddha is trust: enough confidence to try a practice and see what it does. It is tested by experience and is not blind belief. A faith that has been questioned and has come back is usually steadier than one that was never examined. And a person who decides, after honest reflection, that a path is not theirs has also done what Krishna asked.

What helps

When to get more help

If the loss of faith has come with persistent low mood, loss of interest, or hopelessness, see your GP; this can be depression and it is treatable. If you are leaving a controlling group, or your family is in conflict over your beliefs, a counsellor can help you through it. In a crisis, call Lifeline on 13 11 14.

Sources

Summaries and paraphrases are our own; scripture references are given so you can read the texts in a translation you trust.

Common questions

Is it wrong to doubt your faith?
No. The Buddha told the Kalamas their doubt was reasonable (Anguttara Nikaya 3.65), and the Gita ends with Krishna asking Arjuna to reflect fully and then decide for himself (18.63).
What does the Bhagavad Gita say about doubt?
It honours the seeker who questions (7.16, 4.34) and warns against a doubt that never settles (4.40). Its remedy is knowledge: “cut this doubt with the sword of knowledge” (4.42).
What should I do if I have lost my faith?
Give it time, keep one simple practice, put your questions into words, and talk with someone who will not pressure you. If it comes with low mood or isolation, see your GP or a counsellor as well.

If you are full of questions, or your faith has gone quiet, and you would like to talk about it without being told what to believe, you can speak privately with Keshab. It is a spiritual conversation, not therapy or counselling. Talk with Keshab.

In the glossary: Shraddha · Jnana · Viveka · Guru
Related: Choosing a teacher: red flags to know · Spirituality for beginners · What satsang is and how to find one · Quiz: which of the four seekers are you? · Spiritual guidance on life purpose · How to find a spiritual healer or guide · When spiritual practice feels dry
More in Healing: Spiritual Practices for Anxiety and Worry: What the Gita and the Buddha Offer · Stress and Burnout: A Spiritual Perspective from the Gita and the Buddha · Loneliness: Spiritual Practices for Feeling Alone · Heartbreak and the End of a Relationship: A Spiritual Perspective · Anger: Spiritual Practices for Working with Anger · Fear: Spiritual Practices for Courage and Steadiness · Overthinking: How to Quiet a Busy Mind, from the Gita and the Buddha · Sleeplessness: Gentle Spiritual Practices for Restless Nights · Money Worry and Debt Anxiety: A Spiritual Perspective · Losing a Job: A Spiritual Perspective on Redundancy and Starting Again · Career Confusion: Finding Your Svadharma · Business Setbacks and Failure: A Spiritual Perspective · Wealth and Dharma: The Right Relationship with Money in Hindu and Buddhist Teaching · The Path of Knowledge: Self-Inquiry and Vedanta for Advanced Seekers · Spiritual Healing vs Therapy: What Each Offers, and When You Need Which · Life Coach vs Spiritual Guide vs Psychologist: Which Do You Need? · What a Spiritual Healer Does, and What They Should Never Claim · Finding a Spiritual Healer or Guide, Near You or Online · Spiritual Guidance for Anxiety: What It Can Offer, and How It Fits with Therapy · Spiritual Counselling in Australia: Chaplains, Counsellors and Spiritual Guides · Finding a Meditation Teacher Online: What to Look For · Spiritual Support After a Death: Where to Find It and What Helps · Spiritual Support for Low Mood and Depression, Alongside Treatment · What Happens in a Spiritual Guidance Session, and How to Prepare · Spiritual Support for Carers: Looking After Someone Without Losing Yourself · Far From Home: Spiritual Support for Migrants and Families Abroad · Spiritual Support During Serious Illness, for You or Someone You Love · Spiritual Guidance on Life Purpose: What Am I Here For? · Spiritual Support After Miscarriage, Stillbirth or the Loss of a Baby · Spiritual Guidance for Marriage and Relationship Problems · Spiritual Support in Recovery from Alcohol, Drugs or Gambling · Spiritual Guidance for a Big Decision: Seeing Clearly When You Are Torn · Finding an Online Sangha: Spiritual Community When You Cannot Get to One · After Losing Money to a Scam or a Bad Investment: A Spiritual Perspective · Money Pressure in the Family: Supporting Parents, Sending Money Home and Saying No · A Difficult Workplace: Conflict, Unfair Treatment and Bullying, from a Spiritual Perspective · Guilt and Regret: A Spiritual Perspective on Forgiving Yourself · Fear of Death: A Spiritual Perspective and Gentle Practices · Exam Stress and Study Pressure: A Spiritual Perspective for Students · Divorce and Separation: A Spiritual Perspective · Worried About Your Child: A Spiritual Perspective for Parents · Ageing and Retirement: A Spiritual Perspective on Growing Older · When Spiritual Practice Feels Dry: Plateaus, Boredom and Keeping Going · all healing

Walk with us

One passage, one question, every Sunday. Nothing else, ever.