Install Sangha One for a better experience

The Gita for life questions

What the Bhagavad Gita Says About Criticism and Praise

Please note. This is spiritual and educational content. It is not medical, psychological or financial advice, and it is not a substitute for your GP, a psychologist or a financial counsellor. Nothing here is a treatment or cure for any condition.
If you need support now. In Australia, call Lifeline on 13 11 14 (24 hours) or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636 (24 hours). In an emergency, or if you are thinking of harming yourself, call 000. Outside Australia, contact your local crisis line or doctor.

Would it help to talk it through? You can book a private conversation with Keshab when you are ready. It is a spiritual conversation, not coaching, therapy or business advice.

In short. The Gita describes a steady person as one who is “the same in blame and praise” (12.19, 14.24) and in honour and dishonour (6.7). This does not mean deaf to feedback. It means that your sense of who you are does not rise and fall with what is said about you. Praise is not allowed to inflate and criticism is not allowed to crush (2.57). The Gita also sets a standard for your own speech: truthful, kind, helpful and not hurtful (17.15).

The same in blame and praise

Both verses belong to portraits: the first of the devotee who is dear to God, the second of the person who has gone beyond the pull of the three gunas. In each, evenness about what others say sits beside evenness about pleasure and pain. Reputation is treated as one more thing that comes and goes.

Notice that praise is named along with blame. Most of us guard against criticism and welcome praise, but the Gita sees the same hook in both. A person who needs praise can be steered by whoever offers it.

“One to whom blame and praise are alike, who is quiet, content with whatever comes, not tied to any home, steady in mind and full of devotion: that person is dear to me.”

— Bhagavad Gita 12.19

“The same in pleasure and pain, settled in the Self, to whom a clod of earth, a stone and gold are alike, the same towards the pleasant and the unpleasant, steady, and alike in blame and praise.”

— Bhagavad Gita 14.24

Honour and dishonour

Being passed over, overlooked or spoken about unfairly is what the Gita calls dishonour, and it lists it with heat and cold: unpleasant, real, and not a statement about your worth. The steadiness it describes comes from self-mastery and a mind at peace (6.7). It cannot be produced by pretending not to care.

“The same towards friend and enemy, and in honour and dishonour; the same in cold and heat, in pleasure and pain; and free from attachment.”

— Bhagavad Gita 12.18

“For one who has mastered the self and is at peace, the highest Self is steady in cold and heat, in pleasure and pain, and in honour and dishonour.”

— Bhagavad Gita 6.7

Neither elated nor crushed

This is the practical test. After praise, can you carry on working at the same pace? After criticism, can you look at whether it is true without either collapsing or striking back? Chapter 5 repeats the point: the one who knows does not rejoice at the pleasant or grieve at the unpleasant (5.20).

“One who is without attachment in every direction, who neither rejoices nor recoils on meeting with good or bad fortune: that person’s wisdom stands firm.”

— Bhagavad Gita 2.57

What this does not mean

Evenness is not indifference to feedback. The Gita asks for clear understanding of what should and should not be done (18.30), and criticism is sometimes the fastest way to get it. The steady person can hear a hard comment, keep what is true in it and put down the rest.

Nor does it mean putting up with mistreatment. Repeated humiliation, bullying or threats at work or at home are not “criticism” to be borne patiently. They call for action and support. See our page on workplace conflict and bullying.

Your own words

The Gita’s standard for giving criticism has four parts: it should not wound, and it should be true, kind in manner and of some use to the person hearing it. If a comment fails one of these, the tradition’s advice is to wait.

“Speech that does not wound, that is truthful, pleasant and helpful, and the regular recitation of scripture: this is called the discipline of speech.”

— Bhagavad Gita 17.15

Putting it into practice

When other people’s opinions rule your life

If fear of what others think keeps you from speaking, working or leaving the house, or if criticism sends you into days of low mood, that is worth taking to a GP or psychologist. Spiritual practice can sit alongside that help.

Sources

Summaries and paraphrases are our own; scripture references are given so you can read the texts in a translation you trust.

Common questions

What does the Bhagavad Gita say about criticism?
It describes the steady person as “the same in blame and praise” (12.19, 14.24) and in honour and dishonour (6.7). Criticism is to be met without collapse or retaliation, and examined for what is true in it.
Does the Gita say to ignore what others think?
No. It asks that your sense of self should not depend on praise or blame. It also asks for clear understanding (18.30), which means listening to feedback and judging it on its merits.
How should criticism be given, according to the Gita?
Bhagavad Gita 17.15 describes right speech as truthful, pleasant, helpful and not wounding.

If you would like to talk through where you feel stuck, you can book a private 45-minute video conversation with Keshab. It is a spiritual conversation about the Gita’s teaching and your own life, not coaching, therapy or business advice, and it comes with no promise of results. Talk with Keshab.

In the glossary: Equanimity · Gunas · Bhakti · Tapas
Related: The Gita on self-doubt · The Gita on comparison and envy · The Gita on leadership · Workplace conflict and bullying · Anger · Gita quotes on peace
More from the Gita on life questions: What the Bhagavad Gita Says About Fear of Failure · What the Bhagavad Gita Says About Procrastination and Discipline · What the Bhagavad Gita Says About Feeling Empty Despite Success · When Motivation Fades: What the Bhagavad Gita Says About Duty and Devotion · What the Bhagavad Gita Says About Self-Doubt · What the Bhagavad Gita Says About Comparing Yourself to Others · Feeling Stuck: What the Bhagavad Gita Says About the Three Gunas · What the Bhagavad Gita Says About Leadership · all the gita for life questions

Walk with us

One passage, one question, every Sunday. Nothing else, ever.